Judy Malloy

Social Media Archeology



MUDs and MOOs

Poetry Generators

The Electronic Manuscript.

Electronic Literature:
Conferences and Exhibitions

Dene Grigar
Documenting Curation
as Critical Practice

Pathfinders: 25 Years
of Experimental Literary Art, MLA2014 Convention, Chicago

Chercher le texte: the 2013 Conference of the Electronic Literature Organization Brings Electronic Literature to the Public in Paris, September 23-28

E-Poetry 2013, Kingston University, London in June; Program Features Presentations, Exhibitions, Performances, and a Pedagogy Colloquium

With a Theme of "Avenues of Access", MLA2013 Includes an Exhibition of Electronic Literature and over 60 Digital Humanities Panels

Remediating the Social, Edinburgh, November 1-3, 2012

Media Art
Exhibition to be Held
at WVU, June 20-23

Critical Code Studies
Working Group 2012
Reading Code in Context

Belgrade Resonate Festival
March 16-17, 2012

2012 MLA Convention to Feature Elit Panels and Exhibition

Dene Grigar, Lori Emerson,
and Kathi Inman Berens Impact Report for the
Electronic Literature Exhibit at MLA2012

Dangerous Readings
Explores Frontiers
of New Narrative

Elit Well Represented
at ISEA2011

Electronic Literature Organization Moves to MIT

Jef Raskin
The Humane Interface

Brenda Laurel
The Art of Human-Computer Interface Design

Noah Wardrip-Fruin and Nick Montfort, eds.
The New Media Reader

The menu interface to Art Com Electronic Network's Datanet
1986 - 1988. Sysop: Fred Truck. Host: The WELL

Jef Raskin:
The Humane Interface

A leading force in the conception and creation of the Macintosh project for Apple, computer scientist and musician Jef Raskin, (1943-2005) who conducted the San Francisco Chamber Opera Society and played the organ, was an apostle for the design of "humane" interactive user interfaces. Raskin believed that user interface -- the way the user communicates with thee computer -- should be at the core of the design of computers of the future.

His influential book, The Humane Interface, New Directions for Designing Interactive Systems, (Boston: Addison-Wesley, 2000) is a combination of technical and approachable. Merging interface anecdotes and wisdom with detailed information on program design, such as the design of search applications, The Humane Interface is a useful resource for new media writers who create work that situates poetry, narrative, and visual elements in the context of interface design.

Raskin expresses interface strategies that are seemingly simple yet are important. For instance, in discussing the need to consider the role of memory in interface design, he cautions that you can't assume that the user will remember what he or she has seen previously -- a familiar problem for every writer who works with the issue of how the reader will remember the revealed details of character and place. Indeed, questions considered in many of Raskin's discussions -- how the user remembers the interface, what he or she has to do to produce more text, how navigation strategies path the reader -- are of primary interest in the creation of new media literature.

Among the issues the book addresses are:

Visibility versus invisibility -- basically, if you can always see an interface device, it is visible. if you have to remember how to find and use it, it is invisible.

Monotony -- whether or not different ways of doing the same thing are incorporated into the interface

The time it takes for the user to understand the work

Taking into account "habit formation" -- ie wouldn't it be better to give the user a way to undo mistaken commands, rather than asking such questions as "are you sure you want to...", which may be habitually answered "yes".

These issues may not always be important in a work of new media literature, and in some e-literature, either the subverting of such principles underlies the poetics or the revealing of the interface or what the interface reveals contributes to the narrative tension. Thus interface maxims can serve to bring clarity to the issues of interface design while at the same time (to a new media writer) they suggest literary strategies. For instance, the observation that the reader absorbs the workings of the interface at the beginning of the work and then assumes that he or she will always be confronted with it, might be used in one way when narrative flow is important, but in some instances, a new media writer might wish to alter the interface to differentiate time frames or characters.

In the Chapter on "Navigation and Other Aspects of Humane Interfaces", Raskin discusses "intuitive" and "natural" interfaces. Noting that "intuitive" tends to be defined by what the user is used to, he uses as an example Star Trek IV when the former officers of the Enterprise are transported to the 20th century. In one incident, Scotty picks up the mouse of a Macintosh computer and attempts to operate the computer by speaking into the mouse. "Computer..."

Because what the user is accustomed to now drives interface design for many computer systems, Raskin also observes that designing for natural and intuitive interfaces can be detrimental, i.e. there is a conflict between creating something that actually works better and creating something that the user is accustomed to.

The author's attitude to icons may not be well received by visual artists. Nevertheless his question -- wouldn't it be easier to use words than trying to guess or reveal what each little symbol means? -- has some resonance for contemporary desktops, and he provides colorful examples of how icons can be misinterpreted.

His discussion of programming environments, in which he emphasizes the role of documentation in programming creation, is of interest to the contemporary field of literate programming. (Chapter 7 - "Interface Issues Outside the User Interface") Importantly, The Humane Interface is of interest as regards how a seminal figure in interface design looks at interface design.

And all of Jef Raskin's points serve to remind new media artists and writers of the importance of interface.

"An interface is humane if it is responsive to human needs and considerate of human fragilities," he writes. "If you want to create a humane interface, you must have an understanding of the relevant information on how both humans and machines operate. In addition you must cultivate in yourself sensitivity to the difficulties that people experience."

Jef Raskin's The Humane Interface, New Directions for Designing Interactive Systems, is available from Amazon

reviewed by Judy Malloy

Brenda Laurel:
The Art of Human-Computer Interface Design

Interface -- the way the reader (the "user" in computer technology) communicates with the work -- is a primary concern for creators of electronic literature, as well as for readers who want to adventure into new media fiction and poetry. Writers and artists may choose to subvert the principles of interface design, striving in some cases to challenge the reader, or making the interface an actual part of the work. For instance, the interface design principle of "least surprises" might be important in a work of literature in which the content of the text is most important. On the other hand, surprises might be an integral component for writers and artists who design the interface as an integral part of the work itself, rather than as a way of accessing an underlying work. However, it is of interest to understand the principles of interface design, whether we choose to use or subvert them.

The Art of Human-Computer Interface Design is a classic work of Macintosh Interface design. Edited by theater and computers scholar and researcher Brenda Laurel, who was at the time a consultant to Apple Computer and later created Purple Moon software for girls, the book is a formative documentation of the time in history when personal computers were beginning to make new ways of reading and writing possible.Some chapters are probably too Macintosh interface specific to be of interest to all new media writers. Yet the book is very useful. not only from the point of view of historical interface design but also from the point of view of classic approaches to creating interfaces.

For instance, the uses of conversation in interface design -- in particular the simulation of human/human conversation, as opposed to human/computer interaction that does not take this into account -- is addressed by Susan F. Brennan in "Conversation as Direct Manipulation, an Iconoclastic View". Her chapter includes a series of useful examples and discusses how they can be enhanced with graphics.

In "Interface Agents: Metaphors with Character", Brenda Laurel talks about the creation of character in terms of personifying interfaces, using characters in the theatrical sense. Her approach is designed mainly for the creation of interfaces for practical applications, and the interface device of personified "agents" that assist computer users has not become as widely used as anticipated -- perhaps because our relationships with our computers are one-on-one and we may not desire an intermediary, something that was not anticipated in the age of transition from impersonal mainframe to personal computer. Nevertheless, for new media writers who are interested in the traditional literary use of fictional characters as interpreter of events, how this concept was translated into ideas of computer interface agents and guides is of interest in the creation of electronic literature.

In "Guides: Characterizing the Interface", Tim Oren, Gitta Salomon, Kristie Kreitman, and Abbe Don discuss designing an interface for Grolier Electronic Publishing's The Americana Series: America 1800-1850. Fictional characters, represented by graphic images, were used to help young readers select the material most appropriate to their interests. "We are finding out as much about the way people want to receive content as we are about navigation," the authors note. "We have uncovered a lot about what engages in the interface, but we have also discovered that the interface is deeply intermeshed with the content."

Other chapters of particular interest include:

Ronald Baecker and Ian Small, "Animation at the Interface"

Chris Crawford, "Lessons from Computer Game Design"

Abbe Don, "Narrative and the Interface"

Myron W. Kruger, "Videoplace and the Interface of the Future"

S.Joy Mountford and William W. Gaver, "Talking and Listening to Computers"

Michael Naimark, "Realness and Interactivity"

Theodor Holm Nelson, "The Right Way to Think About Software Design"

Tim Oren, "Designing a New Medium"

Howard Rheingold, "What's the Big Deal about Cyberspace?"

Gitta Salomon, "New Uses for Color"

Rob Swigart, "A Writer's Desktop"

"If it is to be like magical paper, then it is the magical part that is all important and that must be most strongly attended to in the user interface design," Alan Kay writes about the computer screen in his chapter "User Interface: A Personal View". Kay also looks at Marshall McLuhan's ideas on how the printing press changed the thought patterns of those who learned to read, observing that "What McLuhan was really saying was that if the personal computer is a truly new medium then the very use of it would actually change the thought patterns of an entire civilization."

Brenda Laurel currently serves as an adjunct professor in Computer Science Department at UC Santa Cruz. She served as professor and founding chair of the Graduate Program in Design at California College of Arts from 2006 to 2012. The Art of Human-Computer Interface Design was conceived of and technically supported by interface designer S. Joy Mountford and is available from Amazon

reviewed by Judy Malloy

The New Media Reader,
edited by Noah Wardrip-Fruin and Nick Montfort

Exploring interface development and in particular narrative and poetic uses of interface in new media literature in a continuing series on interface issues, Authoring Software looks at an important compendium for students and teachers of new media writing practice: The New Media Reader, edited by Noah Wardrip-Fruin and Nick Montfort. (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2003)

A valuable collection of source documents -- presenting over 50 points of view of nnew media history in one volume and including a CD of seminal works -- The New Media Reader forges an original path through the contemporary history of new media up to the development of the World Wide Web. Introductory statements by Janet Murray and Lev Manovich and commentary throughout by the editors, introduce a collection of essays that range from Donna Haraway's influential A Cyborg Manifesto, to an historic introduction to the World Wide Web by Tim Berners-Lee, Robert Cailliau, Ari Loutonen, Henrik Frystyk Nielsen, and Arthur Secret.

" The playful construction within constraints that the Oulipo defined as the role of the author can become an activity extended to readers, who can take place in the interpretation, configuration, and construction of texts."

From the point of view of writing that predated computer-mediated writing but experimented with proto-interface structures in print works, Six Selections by the Oulipo is one of the most interesting sections in The New Media Reader.

Founded in France in 1960 by Raymond Queneau and François Le Lionnais, the group's name is an acronym of Ouvroir de Littérature Potentielle, roughly translated: "workshop of potential literature". Setting the stage for the flowering of French works of digital literature in the 1980's when writers, including Jean-Pierre Balpe and Philippe Bootz, among many others, created works that were actually implemented on computers, Oulipo poets and writers experimented with the very structure of literature, using print and experimental artist book formats. Their writing is particularly interesting in that their strategies in print foresee reader interaction with literature and provide an interesting look at literary systems now implemented by authoring software. "The potential that lies within such an understanding of interactive experiences is a reconfiguration of the relationship between reader, author, and text," Nick Montfort and Noah Wardrip-Fruin write in their introduction to the Oulipo. "The playful construction within constraints that the Oulipo defined as the role of the author can become an activity extended to readers, who can take place in the interpretation, configuration, and construction of texts."

Six Selections by the Oulipo begins with Raymond Queneau's One Hundred Thousand Billion Poems for which he wrote a series of sonnets -- 14 lines of structured poetry -- which are composed so that they can be combined in many different ways and are laid out so that lines can be cut put to reveal a very large number of different poems.

The anticipation/the foresight to see how such an approach might be taken are at the core of the migration of experimental writing from print to new media. Queneau clearly saw this, not only in One Hundred Thousand Billion Poems but also -- running at the bottom of a series of ppages in The New Media Writer -- in his Yours for the Telling in which the adventure story interface of branching paths is anticipated: "Would you prefer the tale of the three, tall lanky beanpoles if so go to 16 if not go to 3."

Following One Hundred Thousand Billion Poems, French poet Jean Lescure's "Brief History of the Oulipo" winds in and and out of the history and goals of the group in a diffuse poetic essay that itself reflects the qualities of the work of this group of poets and writers (of which Lescure was a member) and for whom literary history, the literary qualities of experimental literature. and an exploration/discovery of structure were core as was multiplicity of meanings -- "In short, every literary text is literary because of an indefinite quantity of potential meanings" he states.

Other documents in this section of The New Media Reader include:

Mathematician/writer Claude Berge's "For a Potential Analysis of Combinatory Literature",which begins with forerunners of now computer-mediated strategies in the humanities, such as Mozart's "Musical Game" that allowed people to compose variations on one of his works by combining a series of musical phrases. Berge then displays a -- particularly interesting from an interface point of view -- creative series of systems analysis graphs of literary works with experimental structures, including the work of Queneau and Raymond Roussel, as well as many other approaches that can be expressed with mathematical diagramming. The graphs themselves -- although in the spirit of Oulipo how they might be created differently could be considered -- are of interest to writers of new media literature, whosometimes struggle with ways to map out the structures of their works.

"Computer and Writer: The Centre Pompidou Experiment"
in which French poet, publisher, and diplomat Paul Fournel discusses a series of early experiments -- by Dominique Bourguet, Jean-Pierre Enard and Paul Fournel, and Jean-Pierre Balpe, among others -- both in creating computer-mediated works and in translating works, such Raymond Queneau's, into various kinds of computer-mediated poetry and/or narrative generators.

Italo Calvino was also a member of Oulipo and is represented in this section by Prose and Anticombinatorics, a narrative with programmic solutions to a murder mystery.

In addition to Oulipo, experimental writers in print whose work is featured in The New Media Reader include Jorge Luis Borges, William Burroughs writing on "The Cut Up Method of Brion Gysin", and Augusto Boal.

" On the top are slanting translucent screens, on which material can be projected for convenient reading. There is a keyboard, and sets of buttons and levers. Otherwise it looks like an ordinary desk."

In a series of documents that review the contributions of information science futurists, The New Media Reader documents the history of contemporary creative organization of information with papers by Vannevar Bush, Alan Turing, Norbert Wiener, Theodor H. Nelson, and Douglas Engelbart, among many others.

Many new media artists and writers created their work on separate but parallel tracks. Nevertheless, these papers are of continual interest --not only historically but also in formulating insights and ideas for future directions in the field.

For instance, in 1945, observing that the human mind "operates by association", in his futurist paper "As We May Think", originally published in The Atlantic Monthly and reprinted in The New Media Reader, World War II Director of the US Office of Scientific Research and Development, Vannevar Bush asks readers to:

"Consider a future device for individual use, which is a sort of mechanized private file and library. It needs a name, and to coin one at random,"memex" will do. A memex is a device in which an individual stores all his books,records, and communications, and which is mechanized so that it may be consulted with exceeding speed and flexibility. It is an enlarged intimate supplement to his memory.

It consists of a desk, and while it can presumably be operated from a distance, it is primarily the piece of furniture at which he works. On the top are slanting translucent screens, on which material can be projected for convenient reading. There is a keyboard, and sets of buttons and levers. Otherwise it looks like an ordinary desk."

In the following years, information specialists, such as Henriette Davidson Avram and Ralph H. Parker and many others, both designed and created vast systems of searchable computerized library catalogs that are not represented in this book. [1] These systems were the backbone from which branched (or were created on separate parallel paths) innovative uses of computerized full text information systems on which The New Media Reader focuses, such as the Evolutionary List File (ELF) system proposed in Ted Nelson's classic paper, "A File Structure for the Complex, the Changing, and the Indeterminate" (1965) in which Nelson quotes Vannevar Bush's definition of the memex, addresses the problems of organizing and accessing personal and scholarly information of scholars, and suggests an ELF system using a database based on entries, links, and lists. He coins the word hypertext and imagines full text information systems as containing not only words but also images and film. A primary use of his ELF system is scholarly writing, but he envisions other possibilities.

Also of interest in The New Media Reader is Douglas Engelbart's Augmenting Human Intellect: A Conceptual Framework, as well as classic source documents in computer and information science history that include Ivan Sutherland's "Sketchpad: A Man-Machine Graphical Communication System"; Richard Stallman's "The GNU Manifesto"; Alan Kay and Adele Goldberg's "Personal Dynamic Media"; and Stuart Moulthrop's "You Say You Want a Revolution? Hypertext and the Laws of Media".

" It is our hope that all courses in which The New Media Reader plays a role will include serious study of the digital objects presented here-or of other artifacts, online and off, that don't lend themselves to being reproduced on the printed page. New media cannot be grasped by only consulting secondary sources and critical writing, however important such perspectives may be. Whether our goals include insightful analysis or meaningful new creation, our work should be grounded in interaction with specific new media creations -- as surely as those interested in literature should read literary works, as much as those interested in cinema should watch films."
Web Preface and Guide to the CD - Nick Montfort and Noah Wardrip-Fruin

Outside of Eastgate's continuing importance in publishing hypertext literature and the Electronic Literature Organization's work in this area, early works of new media literature are not always easy to locate or to run.

Thus, it is important that (although some selections require applications that may not be available to every reader) the CD that accompanies The New Media Reader contains a notable collection of interesting selections of pre-World Wide Web new media writing and games, beginning (as regards games and works of art) with Stephen Russell's legendary Spacewar! and also including Gregory Yob's Hunt the Wumpus, Adventure, Jim Rosenberg's Diagram Series 3 and 4, Judy Malloy's collaborative literary authoring system, You!, Robert Kendall's The Clue, poems by John Cayley, and Writing on the Hypertextual Edge, edited by Stuart Moulthrop, a section of the Spring 1991 issue of Writing on the Edge, which includes Izme Pass by Carolyn Guyer and Martha Petry, as well as Michael Joyce's WOE.

" What McCloud's work nevertheless shows is that new forms, even those that have not been studied seriously for centuries or even decades, do indeed have certain conventions and rules, and that if the form being studied is considered with care and thought, these rules can be determined, benefitting those who work in the form, who are striving to improve the practice of their art." -- Nick Montfort

As regards the creation of interface, The New Media Reader is particularly useful to new media writers in presenting an overall picture of historic approaches. The book also reprints quite a few papers that are specifically helpful to designers of interfaces for new media literature. They include:

Richard A. Bolt, "'Put-That-There': Voice and Gesture at the Graphics Interface"

Lucy A. Suchman, two excerpts from her book Plans and Situated Actions: The Problem of Human-machine Communication

The first addresses navigation -- as an example of different approaches, contrasting European style navigation, which begins with a plan, with Trukese navigation which begins with an objective; the second addresses interactivity, which she approaches from a anthropology/sociology point of view that might inspire conceptions of how narrative can be differently considered for "interactive artifacts".

Scott McCloud's "Time Frames" (from his book Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art)

Brenda Laurel, "The Six Elements and Causal Relations Among Them" (from her book Computers as Theater) and "Star Raiders: Dramatic Interaction in a Small World" (from her PhD thesis)

J. David Bolter, from his book Writing Space: The Computer, Hypertext, and the History of Writing, a selection entitled "Seeing and Writing", which looks at the visual aspects of the "Electronic Page."

Additionally, The New Media Reader hosts a series of papers that look at creative new media in learning environments. For instance telemative narrative pioneer Roy Ascott is represented with "The Construction of Change", an essay with a central focus on an education of artists that includes cybernetics. And Michael Joyce's "Siren Shapes: Exploratory and Constructive Hypertexts" focuses on classroom uses of StorySpace and hypertext.

More information about , The New Media Reader is available on the MIT Press website at http://mitpress.mit.edu/catalog/item/default.asp?ttype=2&tid=9604

and on the book's website at http://www.newmediareader.com/index.html

The Table of Contents is listed at http://www.newmediareader.com/book_contents.html

The CD Table of Contents is listed at

reviewed by Judy Malloy


1. Queens College CUNY, Library Technology Timeline
Books on the development of the personal computer are also a recommended supplement to The New Media Reader. Although it is now taken for granted, creators who used punchcards and mainframe computers in the 1960's and earlier (I worked for a contractor of the Goddard Space Center Libraries computer catalog in 1967 and later headed the team that designed and programmed the Ball Brothers Research Corporation Library computerized catalog in 1969) know how important the work of Gary Kildall, Ed Roberts, Steve Wozniak, Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, Xerox PARC, Lee Felsenstein, Don Estridge, (as well as many others, such as Douglas Engelbart and Alan Kay, whose work is included in The New Media Reader) did to invent and produce the personal computer systems we use to create contemporary new media art.

Also recommended as supplemental source material are publications about seminal art telecom systems, such as Heidi Grundmann, Editor, Art Telecommunication, Vancouver, Canada: Western Front; Wien, Austria: Blix, 1984 and Roy Ascott and Carl Eugene Loeffler, Guest Editors, Connectivity: Art and Interactive Telecommunications, Leonardo 24:2, 1991.

For information about the Authoring Software resource, email Judy Malloy at: jmalloy@well.com Suggestions for inclusion are welcome!

last update March 22, 2014

Authoring Software

Resources and Blogs

Electronic Literature Organization
__Electronic Literature Directory

Mark Bernstein

J. R. Carpenter - lapsus linguae

J. R. Carpenter
Jacket 2:
Performing Digital Texts in European Contexts

Center for Digital Storytelling

Center for Literary Computing,
West Virginia University

Shu Lea Cheang

Critical Code Studies (HaCCS Lab)

Digital Language Arts (Brown University)

Electronic Book Review

Electronic Literature as a Model of
Creativity and Innovation in Practice

__ELMCIP Knowledge Base

Electronic Poetry Center - E-Poetry

expressive intelligence studio
(University of California, Santa Cruz)

Lori Emerson

Field Guide to Digital Fiction

Leonardo Flores
I ♥ E-Poetry


Gnoetry Daily

Grand Text Auto

Dene Grigar,
and Stuart Moulthrop

Fox Harrell: Ice Lab


Hermeneia - Literary Studies and Digital Technologies Research Project



Institute for the Future of the Book

Interactive Fiction Wiki

IF-Review - The Online Interactive Fiction Review Site

Chris Joseph

Deena Larsen's Fundamentals

The Literary Platform

Mark Marino: WRT: Writer Response Theory

Cathy Marshall

Nick Montfort
__Post Position


NT2 - Nouvelles technologies, nouvelles textualités
(University of Quebec in Montreal)

Planet Interactive Fiction

Rita Raley

Jill Walker Rettberg

Scott Rettberg

Marie-Laure Ryan

Emily Short - Blog

Software Studies at UCSD

Sue Thomas: Writing and the Digital Life

TrAce Archive




El Relato Digital

WRT: Interactive Entertainment Software